Back to the archive

The encyclopedia · Product & Design · Product decision · 2012–2019

YotaPhone: the dual-screen e-ink phone that talked itself to death

A Russian phone with an e-Ink back display sold ~75,000 units across two models, then Yota Devices was wound up in 2019 after a $126 million order dispute.

Yota Devices · 2019-04-11

What happened

YotaPhone was a Russian smartphone with a novel pitch: a colour LCD on the front and a power-sipping e-Ink display on the back, so users could read books, notifications and maps on a screen that almost never drained the battery. The first YotaPhone launched in December 2012, pitched at an international market that had never heard of a Russian phone brand.

The pitch travelled better than the product. The first two YotaPhones together sold roughly 75,000 units — a niche even by the standards of a niche phone. YotaPhone 2 failed to ship to the US in 2015 despite exceeding its Indiegogo crowdfunding goal, and in late 2016 Yota pulled out of Russia and Europe entirely, shifting operations to China. YotaPhone 3 sold only in China despite promises of wider release.

The end came through the supply chain. Manufacturer Hi-P Singapore sued Yota for $126 million in 2015 after Yota refused to take delivery of — and pay for — the minimum phone order it had agreed to. Hi-P later agreed to settle for $17 million, but that deal fell through. A liquidation notice was published in the Cayman Islands Gazette in April 2019: Yota Devices, hamstrung by an inventory commitment it could not honour because nobody was buying, was declared bankrupt.

Why it happened

  • YotaPhone sold a demo, not a daily use case: the e-Ink back screen reviewed beautifully but gave buyers a second display they rarely opened on a mid-range Android.
  • A Russian consumer brand tried to jump straight to a global market without the distribution or brand trust to carry it — two models sold only ~75,000 units against the scale ordered.
  • Yota committed to a large minimum order with Hi-P, then could not take delivery as sales never materialised — the $126 million dispute over that order wound the company up.
What it costBankrupt 2019; ~75,000 sold; $126M order lawsuitcostly

The lesson

A feature that demos well is not a reason to buy. YotaPhone's e-Ink back screen made a great pitch but a thin daily case, and the order outlasted the demand.

Aftermath

Yota Devices was declared bankrupt by the Cayman Islands Supreme Court in April 2019 and FTI Consulting was appointed liquidator. The YotaPhone brand did not survive as a going concern.

Sources

spotted an error? The club wants to know.

Comments · 0

    Sign in to join the comments.

    More like this

    Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →