The encyclopedia · R&D & Science · Technical decision · 1943
GE tried to make synthetic rubber — it got a bouncing putty that went to the moon
GE was chasing a synthetic rubber for the war and got a putty that bounced. A toy shop put it in plastic eggs, and Apollo 8 took it to lunar orbit.
General Electric · Binney & Smith · 1949
What happened
In 1943, during World War II, the United States faced a critical shortage of natural rubber after Japan invaded the rubber-producing countries of Southeast Asia. General Electric chemist James Wright was assigned to develop a synthetic rubber substitute. He mixed boric acid with silicone oil in a test tube and got a gooey, bouncing putty that stretched farther than rubber and bounced higher than a rubber ball.
The putty had one fatal flaw: it was useless as rubber. It bounced, stretched, and picked up newsprint like a printing press, but it lacked the strength and elasticity needed for tires, gaskets, or any other wartime application. GE sent samples to scientists around the world, hoping someone could find a practical use. Nobody could. The project was abandoned.
In 1949, toy store owner Ruth Fallgatter discovered the putty at a party and began selling it through her catalogue. Marketing consultant Peter Hodgson saw the potential. He borrowed $147, bought a batch of the putty, packed 1-ounce portions into plastic eggs, and named it Silly Putty. After a New Yorker magazine article mentioned the product, Hodgson sold over 250,000 eggs in three days.
The Korean War in 1951 caused a silicone shortage that halted production for a year, but by 1955 most buyers were children aged 6 to 12. The first TV commercial aired in 1957 on the Howdy Doody Show. In 1968, Apollo 8 astronauts took Silly Putty into lunar orbit, where it was used to secure tools in zero gravity. By 2009, over 300 million eggs had been sold. Binney & Smith (Crayola) acquired the brand in 1977.
Why it happened
- James Wright was trying to make a synthetic rubber substitute for the war effort and got a bouncing putty that was useless for every military application it was tested against.
- GE sent the putty to scientists worldwide looking for a practical use — nobody found one, and the project was abandoned as a failed experiment.
- The putty sat unused for six years until a toy store owner and a marketing consultant saw its potential — not as an industrial material, but as a children's toy.
The lesson
A material that fails its purpose is a material still looking for its problem. The putty was no use for a war and exactly right for a toy — and later for holding tools down in zero gravity.
Sources
- A Successful Failure — Science History Institute
- Silly Putty — Wikipedia (invention, history, commercialization)
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
3M's Post-it Notes were a failed glue that became a global office staple
Teflon was a failed refrigerant that became the world's slipperiest surface
Raytheon's radar melted a chocolate bar — the microwave oven was born
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.