The encyclopedia · Product & Design · Product decision · 2020-2021
Sega shut down a big mobile game 7 months in, still earning tens of millions monthly
Sakura Kakumei launched in December 2020 as a big-budget spiritual successor to Sakura Wars, and Sega ended service in July 2021 rather than keep running it.
Sega · Delightworks · 2021-06-30
What happened
Sega published Sakura Kakumei ~Hanasaku Otome-tachi~, developed by Delightworks (the studio behind Fate/Grand Order), as a big-budget mobile gacha game and a spiritual successor to the beloved Sakura Wars franchise, launching in December 2020 after a large investment in production and voice talent.
The game struggled to build a sustainable player base in its first months despite the pedigree of its developer and IP connection, falling well short of the retention and revenue benchmarks a production of its scale needed to justify continued investment.
Sega announced the game's shutdown in June 2021, ending service in July — roughly seven months after launch — while Japanese reporting noted the game was still generating tens of millions of yen a month, meaning Sega chose to walk away from ongoing revenue rather than continue supporting a title it judged wasn't going to recoup its development cost.
Why it happened
- The studio committed a large production budget to a spiritual successor without first validating demand at that investment scale.
- Early performance metrics after launch signaled the game wouldn't hit sustainable retention, but the launch had already locked in the cost.
- Sega prioritized cutting losses on a large sunk development cost over continuing to operate a game still generating revenue.
- Planned content, including guest voice work already contracted, had to be cancelled once the shutdown decision was made.
The lesson
A game can still be making money and still be the wrong bet, if the money it's making can't catch up to what it cost to build.
Aftermath
The shutdown became a widely discussed case in Japanese games media about how quickly a big-budget mobile title can be judged a loss even while still profitable month to month, once development costs are factored into the calculation.
Sources
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Foamstars: Square Enix's live-service shooter went free-to-play in eight months
Babylon's Fall: PlatinumGames' live-service gamble shut down in 11 months
Babylon's Fall shipped as an always-online game and fell to 1 PC player within months
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.