The encyclopedia · Strategy & Leadership · Strategic decision · 2003–2012
S-Fone bet $543M on CDMA in Vietnam — GSM had already won
S-Fone launched Vietnam's first CDMA network in 2003 with $543M. GSM won, subscribers dropped to 0.1%, and the network shut down in 2012.
S-Fone · S-Telecom · SK Telecom · Saigon Postel (SPT)
What happened
S-Fone launched in July 2003 as Vietnam's first CDMA mobile network, a joint venture between Saigon Postel (SPT) and South Korea's SK Telecom. It was the country's third mobile operator and promised better voice quality and data speeds than the GSM networks already operating. By early 2005 it had 1.5 million subscribers.
But GSM was the global standard, and Vietnamese consumers preferred its cheaper handsets and international roaming. By 2008 S-Fone had grown to 3.1 million subscribers, and its owners announced a $543 million infrastructure investment — but the network never turned a profit. GSM operators Viettel, MobiFone, and VinaPhone used their scale to undercut S-Fone on price and coverage.
SK Telecom exited the joint venture in 2010. Without its Korean partner's capital and technology, S-Fone quickly collapsed. By 2012 its market share had fallen to 0.1%, stores closed, staff were laid off, and the network was shut down. The CDMA license expired unused in 2016 — a $543 million bet on the wrong technology.
Why it happened
- S-Fone launched Vietnam's first CDMA mobile network in 2003, backed by SK Telecom, when GSM was already the global standard and Vietnamese competitors were using GSM.
- By 2008 S-Fone had 3.1M subscribers and invested $543M, but GSM operators MobiFone, VinaPhone, and Viettel grew faster with cheaper handsets and wider roaming.
- SK Telecom exited the joint venture in 2010, leaving Saigon Postel (SPT) without capital or technical support.
- By 2012 S-Fone's market share had fallen to 0.1%, it could not pay salaries, and the network was shut down — the CDMA license expired unused in 2016.
The lesson
Betting on a losing technology standard, even with first-mover advantage, is not recoverable.
Aftermath
After S-Fone ceased operations in July 2012, its 3.1 million subscribers were left without service. Saigon Postel (SPT) could not find a new investor. The CDMA license expired in 2016. SK Telecom had already written off its investment. The Vietnamese mobile market was left to three GSM operators — Viettel, MobiFone, and VinaPhone — which remain dominant today.
Sources
- S-Fone — Wikipedia
- S-Fone $543M investment — web search citation
- TelecomDrive — Vietnam might cancel licenses of S-Fone and EVN Telecom
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Hutchison ran a loss-making Macau mobile network for 25 years, then sold it for HK$110M
EchoStar bet everything on spectrum — then lost $14.5B in a year
Sendo shut down twice — FPT's 14-year e-commerce bet collapsed in two stages
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.