The encyclopedia · Finance & Accounting · Financial decision · 2024
NYCB doubled its balance sheet, then wrote off $2.4B and its CEO
A surprise Q4 loss and a 71% dividend cut dropped NYCB's stock ~37%; weeks came a $2.4B goodwill charge, a material weakness and a new CEO.
New York Community Bancorp · 2024-01-31
What happened
New York Community Bancorp spent 2022–23 assembling a much bigger bank: it bought Flagstar Bank, then took the deposits and branches of failed Signature Bank in the March 2023 rescue, ending the year with $116.3 billion of assets and a new regulatory label — a Category IV bank with stricter capital and liquidity demands. The deals left NYCB concentrated in commercial real estate and multifamily lending just as office values were falling.
On 31 January 2024 the bill arrived: a surprise fourth-quarter net loss of $252 million, driven by $552 million of loan-loss provisions and $185 million of charge-offs tied largely to one co-op loan and one office loan, with the dividend cut 71% to $0.05 a share. The stock fell about 37% in a day, dragging regional banks with it. Then late February: a $2.4 billion goodwill impairment, chief executive Thomas Cangemi out, replaced by Alessandro DiNello — the former CEO of Flagstar, the bank NYCB had bought — plus a material weakness in internal loan review and a delayed annual filing.
The first quarter of 2024 added another loss, and the turnaround fell to the man who had run the acquired bank. NYCB became the test case for whether buying a failed bank is a bargain: the deposits came cheap; the credit risk stayed.
Why it happened
- Two acquisitions in one year pushed the bank past the threshold for stricter regulation exactly when its core CRE lending was turning.
- Loan review was weak enough to be declared a material weakness — office credits were re-marked only as charge-offs surfaced in results.
- The dividend was the story the stock was priced on; cutting it 71% in one quarter repriced the whole thesis at once.
The lesson
Buying a failed bank's deposits is cheap because the risk stays in the loan book. The regulatory bill is due the day the deal closes; the credit bill arrives whenever it wants.
Sources
- Banking Dive — NYCB names DiNello as CEO, takes $2.4B impairment charge, 1 Mar 2024
- The Bank Slate — New York Community slashes dividend after surprise 4Q loss, Jan 2024
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
International Paper wrote off $2.47B of DS Smith goodwill a year after buying it
Smucker wrote its Hostess goodwill down to zero within two years of the $5.6B deal
Forward Air wrote down $1B of its $2.1B Omni acquisition a year after closing it
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →
Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.