The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2025
Molloy's Liquor Stores' AI-written Buckfast ad banned for 'grab a bottle (or ten)'
An AI tool drafted Molloy's Buckfast ad copy: drinkers would feel 'like a superhero', with memory-loss testimonials. ASAI said it encouraged excess.
Molloy's Liquor Stores · 2025-12
What happened
An AI writing tool drafted the on-site copy for Buckfast Tonic Wine on Molloy's Liquor Stores' website. It asked drinkers if they were 'tired of regular old wine', claimed the tonic would make them feel 'like a superhero' and 'on top of the world', and urged them to grab 'a bottle (or ten)'.
The testimonials pushed it further: 'I drank Buckfast before my job interview and I got the job! I don't remember much of the interview', 'I had a glass before my wedding and I don't remember saying I do', and 'Buckfast is the only thing that gets me through family gatherings'.
A complainant said the ad was irresponsible: it implied alcohol improved performance and that drinkers relied on it to function socially. ASAI's Independent Council agreed, finding the ad centred on the product's effects, implied memory loss, and encouraged excessive consumption, breaching sections 9.1, 9.5(a)(b) and 9.8(a)(b)(f)(g).
Molloy's conceded the wording could be read as inconsistent with the Code, removed the complained-about copy and replaced it with a factual product description, apologised for the 'unintended impression', and said it would add internal checks so AI-assisted content is reviewed for compliance before publication.
Why it happened
- The AI wrote copy that bragged about memory loss and 'grab a bottle (or ten)' — the exact binge-drinking fantasy alcohol advertising exists to avoid
- The brand conceded the problem and pulled the ad itself, so this was an own-goal as much as a regulator decision
- The loophole is spreading: AI-drafted ad copy shipped without a human compliance read
The lesson
AI copy needs a human compliance read. The tool wrote 'grab a bottle (or ten)' and memory-loss testimonials — a human would have caught that instantly. The brand's fix: pull, apologise, review.
Aftermath
The advertisement was to be removed in its current form. Molloy's said it had already withdrawn the copy on receiving the complaint and replaced it with a factual description, apologised, and committed to internal checks so AI-assisted content is reviewed for code compliance before going live. ASAI used the case to advise advertisers to review content before publication.
Sources
- ASAI Complaint Decisions, Bulletin 25/6 (Dec 2025): Alcohol — Molloy's Liquor Stores (ref 44782)
- ASAI Bulletin 25/6 index (Dec 2025)
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Hollandsnieuwe's 'doubled, sharper-priced' bundles — the €4.50 lasted only 12 months
Scoupy's 'Extra cashback €30' health-switch ad upheld for hiding the deal had ended
Nissan's '80 kW fast-charging' Townstar ad upheld as misleading by the Dutch RCC
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.