The encyclopedia · Advertising & PR · Marketing decision · 2020
Warner Bros dropped its Grindelwald four days after a judge called him a wife beater
A UK court found The Sun's 'wife beater' claim substantially true; Warner Bros asked Depp to resign within four days, and a planned five films became three.
Warner Bros · 2020-11-06
What happened
Johnny Depp had played the villain Grindelwald in the Fantastic Beasts series since 2016, the centrepiece of a planned five-film franchise. On 2 November 2020 the UK High Court ruled against him in his libel case against The Sun, finding the paper's 'wife beater' claim substantially true — 12 of the 14 alleged incidents of domestic violence had occurred.
Four days later Warner Bros asked him to resign from the role, and he agreed, saying he had 'respected and agreed to that request'. The studio thanked him for his work and said the part would be recast; the third film had not yet begun filming, so no footage was lost.
The franchise never recovered. The Secrets of Dumbledore, released in April 2022 with a new actor in the role, opened to the series' lowest box-office and became the lowest-grossing Wizarding World film. By November 2022 Warner Bros had no script for a fourth or fifth film in development, and in October 2023 director David Yates said the series was 'parked'.
Why it happened
- Warner Bros had bet a five-film franchise on a star whose conduct risk was public since 2016; the High Court ruling turned allegations into a judicial finding, leaving no ground to keep him.
- The judgment gave the studio four days of runway — from 2 November to 6 November — too short for the controversy to cool, so the exit was the only low-cost option left.
- Recasting did not reset the damage: the third film still carried the franchise's cost structure, and made without Depp it fell to the lowest-grossing Wizarding World film, ending the five-film plan.
The lesson
A franchise built on one star inherits that star's legal risk: once a court found the claims substantially true, the studio had four days and no choice that kept the series' value.
Aftermath
Depp later won a US defamation case against Amber Heard in June 2022, but never returned to the franchise. The role was recast, The Secrets of Dumbledore underperformed, and in October 2023 Yates said the films were 'all just parked' — no fourth film has been announced since.
Sources
- Johnny Depp leaves Fantastic Beasts film franchise — BBC, 6 Nov 2020
- Johnny Depp loses libel case over Sun 'wife beater' claim — BBC, 2 Nov 2020
- 'Fantastic Beasts' director says franchise is on 'a pause' — LA Times, 27 Oct 2023
spotted an error? The club wants to know.
More like this
Warner Bros bet $220M on Ezra Miller — and released a bomb it couldn't promote
A Cupshe staffer emailed 'we would not collab with black people' — hired four days earlier
Growth Cave sold 'AI software' that automated almost nothing — the FTC made it pay $48.6M
Somewhere, someone solved the problem this company failed at. 2nd Opinion →

Comments · 0
Sign in to join the comments.